Statistics
- Total Options: 50
- Total Votes: 262
Current Rankings
- #1 Pepperoni (Elo: 1359, Matches: 15)
- #2 Italian sausage (Elo: 1341, Matches: 14)
- #3 Capicola (Elo: 1302, Matches: 12)
- #4 Mushrooms (Elo: 1301, Matches: 11)
- #5 Salami (Elo: 1294, Matches: 9)
- #6 Hot honey (Elo: 1287, Matches: 13)
- #7 Sausage (Elo: 1278, Matches: 8)
- #8 Pepperoncini (Elo: 1276, Matches: 10)
- #9 Bacon (Elo: 1276, Matches: 8)
- #10 Chicken (Elo: 1272, Matches: 14)
- #11 Pineapple (Elo: 1268, Matches: 11)
- #12 Banana peppers (mild) (Elo: 1264, Matches: 9)
- #13 Green peppers (Elo: 1250, Matches: 10)
- #14 Buffalo chicken (Elo: 1246, Matches: 9)
- #15 Red peppers (Elo: 1235, Matches: 9)
- #16 Grilled chicken (Elo: 1218, Matches: 15)
- #17 Steak (Elo: 1218, Matches: 14)
- #18 Red onions (Elo: 1211, Matches: 8)
- #19 Cherry peppers (Elo: 1209, Matches: 12)
- #20 Banana peppers (Elo: 1209, Matches: 7)
- #21 Extra cheese (Elo: 1208, Matches: 11)
- #22 Canadian bacon (Elo: 1208, Matches: 8)
- #23 Pancetta (Elo: 1201, Matches: 12)
- #24 Pesto (Elo: 1199, Matches: 2)
- #25 Prosciutto (Elo: 1193, Matches: 13)
- #26 Caramelized onions (Elo: 1190, Matches: 10)
- #27 Garlic (Elo: 1188, Matches: 7)
- #28 Habanero peppers (Elo: 1187, Matches: 11)
- #29 Lobster (Elo: 1186, Matches: 12)
- #30 Ground beef (Elo: 1186, Matches: 5)
- #31 Roasted garlic (Elo: 1184, Matches: 12)
- #32 JalapeƱos (Elo: 1180, Matches: 7)
- #33 Spicy sausage (Elo: 1180, Matches: 12)
- #34 BBQ chicken (Elo: 1180, Matches: 13)
- #35 Red chili flakes (Elo: 1179, Matches: 8)
- #36 Philly steak (Elo: 1175, Matches: 11)
- #37 Onions (Elo: 1171, Matches: 6)
- #38 Serrano peppers (Elo: 1167, Matches: 12)
- #39 Crab (Elo: 1164, Matches: 9)
- #40 Shrimp (Elo: 1153, Matches: 10)
- #41 Chorizo (Elo: 1144, Matches: 12)
- #42 Pulled pork (Elo: 1144, Matches: 15)
- #43 Roasted red peppers (Elo: 1139, Matches: 9)
- #44 Meatballs (Elo: 1115, Matches: 10)
- #45 Black olives (Elo: 1115, Matches: 13)
- #46 Poblano peppers (Elo: 1112, Matches: 14)
- #47 Green olives (Elo: 1111, Matches: 13)
- #48 Ham (Elo: 1095, Matches: 8)
- #49 Anchovies (Elo: 1094, Matches: 8)
- #50 Clams (Elo: 1047, Matches: 13)
Vote Now
Help rank these options by voting: Start Voting